Each week you'll learn how to be a better dividend investor and follow the journey of a welder with a passion for passive income to $1,000,000 and beyond.
Share
What 266 Stock Picks Taught Me...
Published about 6 hours ago • 4 min read
YouTube is full of "buy these 5 cheap stocks NOW" videos because they're easy to make. But few of those creators are actually buying those stocks—and even fewer list every pick and track it in public, forever.
I do. Every pick, tracked from the day the video dropped. No deleting the losers and no cherry-picking.
Five years and 266 picks later, the sheet has taught me some things I didn't expect:
1. I'm wrong more than it feels like.
63% winners, 37% losers. More than 1 in 3 picks lost money.
2. A tiny handful of picks did almost all the work.
38 picks doubled or better — Eli Lilly (LLY) +410%, Caterpillar (CAT) +347%. Just 10 picks produced about a third of ALL the gains. Meanwhile 27 picks lost HALF or more, and a few went basically to zero.
3. I couldn't have told you which 10 they'd be.
Hell no. I thought Caterpillar was an incredibly boring pick.
4. Several "safe" names were a trap.
Clorox (CLX)? I picked it 4 times. Lost all 4. A household name everybody calls safe.
5. Average and typical aren't the same thing.
Average pick: +33%. The typical (median) pick: only +18%. The big winners pull that average up and make everything look better than it was.
Quick note: my sheet tracks price only — no dividends paid or reinvested. Since most of these are dividend payers, the real total returns are higher. But simple price return puts us in the ballpark, and I'd rather undersell than oversell.
6. The boring easy button kept up with all of it.
Since January 2021, VOO returned 125% with dividends reinvested. Even without reinvesting a single dividend, it's up 119%. Zero research. Zero stress.
DividendChannel.com
7. Being IN the market beats being clever about the market.
Yes, this was one of history's longest bull markets. That's the point — nobody knew that in advance. You only catch the huge up days by already being there when they show up.
8. Plan, don't predict.
If I had to guess, we'll see a severe downturn or two in the next ten years. But even the experts get the timing wrong. Here's what we do know: if American businesses keep growing and innovating, they'll make more money. Rising earnings pull the market higher — just like they have throughout history.
TKer by Sam Ro
So here's where five years of tracking left me: Make an index fund like VOO or VTI the core. Sprinkle in a dividend growth fund like SCHD. Then treat individual picks as the smaller satellite holdings to fulfill something you want more of like dividend income or international stocks.
I'll keep making the pick videos. I'll keep updating the sheet. And you can keep checking the results anytime.
Brian Bollinger at SimplySafeDividends.com ran a $1M portfolio comparison of Dividend Aristocrats (companies in the S&P 500 index that have increased its dividend payout for at least 25 consecutive years) and the ever popular SCHD. Most of you will be pleased with the result...
It isn't everyday when you hear someone new who has really interesting things to say about investing and investor psychology. But, Paula Pant had on historian Joseph Moore who thinks were living in the best era ever... oh, and they kick off the episode recapping his stunt that made him a *legitimate* billionaire!
Disclaimer: This is not investment advice. Do your own research before making any investment decisions.
😁THANK YOU to all who responded to the last newsletter!!
Simply Safe Dividends is a resource I use every single day. It's run by a handful of very knowledgable HUMANS and updated constantly. And with this offer, you can try it FREE for one full month with absolutely NO credit card required! 👉Check it out!
Access Seeking Alpha's proven stock ratings, data-driven insights, and institutional-grade tools for just $269 for your first year.:
If you want data-driven insights and professional stock ratings to help grow your portfolio, grab the deal while it lasts. 👉 [Claim your discount here!]
*These are affiliate offers, and I will receive a small commission at no additional cost when you buy a premium annual subscription after clicking the images or links above.
Each week you'll learn how to be a better dividend investor and follow the journey of a welder with a passion for passive income to $1,000,000 and beyond.
Last week I told you Watsco (WSO) pays out 67% of its free cash flow and called it "comfortably boring." Welp, fellow YouTuber and community member Kevin Burgess, who is a retired CPA, schooled me, and I want to share that with you. First and most importantly, Watsco doesn't own everything on its own financial statements... They run six joint ventures with Carrier — the company that makes most of the equipment they sell. Watsco owns 80% of five of them, 60% of the Canadian one. Carrier owns...
Watsco (WSO) has printed new shares every single year for a decade. Not most years. Every. single. Year. 32.6 million shares in 2016. 38.0 million today. Share dilution is one of my bugaboos. Every new share carves a little off my slice. So when I saw that chart, it was a tougher pill to swallow. But swallow I did and started a position this week, and here's why: A rising share count is kind of like a check engine light. Nine times out of ten, it means something is actually wrong under the...
Papa John's (PZZA) was yielding over 6% and that dividend looked shiny and tempting. I'm not going to pretend I didn't notice. It's been sitting on the fringes of my radar for a couple years now, price sliding, yield climbing and my daughter loves their pizza. (Reminder: liking the product doesn't make it a good investment. Plenty of us loved Blockbuster Video too.) Being attracted to a fat yield is fine. Normal, even. A largemouth bass sees something shiny and thinks food. The bass just...
