Should I Dump My REITs?


I own Agree Realty (ADC) and VICI Properties (VICI). And as interest rates keep climbing, they keep sinking.

I bought my first ADC shares on 2/21/2024 at $56.85. My first VICI shares were on 9/22/2023 at $29.95 and I have kept adding to both in my self-directed IRA at Schwab. REIT dividends get taxed like regular income, so the IRA pushes that tax bill down the road.

So why do I own them? ADC is the easy way to own quality commercial real estate. VICI owns some of the most famous casinos on the Las Vegas Strip. Diversification, plus a paycheck.

But as the prices drop, they shrink in my portfolio. ADC is now about 2.6%. VICI is about 1.5%.

Here's what got me thinking. In this month's Intelligent Income newsletter, Brian Bollinger at Simply Safe Dividends pitched Realty Income (O) as an investment idea. Because the 10-year Treasury is above 5%, you can earn solid income with zero stock risk. So investors want a bigger yield from REITs and the only way to get it is lower share prices. Brian still likes the business because it's about 99% leased, has an A- credit rating, and has raised its dividend every year since 1994.

Then he closed by saying Realty Income is for "investors who value dependable monthly income."

That line created quite a bit of mental tension, because I'm 48 and years away from depending on my portfolio for income.

Some people hate this comparison, but I did it anyway. I stacked my REITs up against the S&P 500 (VOO), with dividends reinvested.

$10,000 in ADC is now about $12,950. That's up 29.50%. The same $10,000 in VOO is now about $16,020. That's up 60.18%. ADC was ahead for a while, but not anymore.

$10,000 in VICI is now about $9,100. That's down 9.00%. The same $10,000 in VOO is now about $18,590. That's up 85.87%. VICI has never been ahead. Not once.

I can already hear the pushback: "It's not fair to compare a REIT to a tech-heavy index." I don't care. VOO is the ultimate "know nothing" easy button, and if I can't beat it, I need a good reason to own something else.

Steven Bavaria gives one in his book The Income Factory. He says to think of your portfolio like a factory and what matters is the cash it pumps out. You reinvest that cash, and the income keeps growing. The share price going up isn't the point.

And I get it. A REIT is about income first with share price a distant second.

But it all comes down to one question: Do you want more diversification and more income now? Or more of 500 of America's biggest companies, and probably more money later?

If rates fall, REITs should bounce back as yield hunters return. But nobody knows when, or if.

If I sell all my REITs and put that money in the S&P 500, I'd likely end up with a bigger pile. And when I need income, I can swap part of that pile into REITs, MLPs, or BDCs.

But I already have about 60% in S&P 500 funds (65% if you count VTI). Piling into what's working works... until it doesn't.

Right now I'm leaning toward keeping my REITs as a portfolio diversifier and focusing on the quality of the companies and the income they make. But I'd be lying if I said I wasn't tempted to move my REIT and BDC money, about 7% of my portfolio, into more S&P 500.

What would you do? Hit reply and tell me. I'd love to hear it.


Video I'm Watching

video preview​

Toby and Jake chatted with Jonathan Boyar about beaten down compounders, and even touched on several dividend paying companies like Restaurant Brands International (QSR) and Pool Corp (POOL).

Podcast I'm Listening To

show
How to Create a Million-Doll...
Oct 2 · Value Investor
41:40
Spotify Logo
 
​

Very cool episode from Tracey Ryniec about how a few non-professional investors created multi-million dollar portfolios, and what lessons we can take away from them to do the same.


Disclaimer: This is not investment advice. Do your own research before making any investment decisions.

😁THANK YOU to all who responded to the last newsletter!!

Check out the portfolio on Blossom, the podcast, or see what’s cooking on YouTube.

And now, here is this week's portfolio activity...


Dividends Received This Week ~$591.15

  • Schwab Intl. Dividend ETF (SCHY) | $5.06
  • Schwab U.S. Dividend ETF (SCHD) | $179.09
  • Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (VTI) | $31.53
  • Ares Capital (ARCC) | $312.00
  • Main Street Capital (MAIN) | $45.00
  • Amplify Intl. Dividend Income ETF (IDVO) | $18.47

Dividends Received 2026 (Schwab Only)~

$4,034.45


Stocks Sold (AVERAGE)

  • 2 Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (VTI) | $375.69

Stocks Bought (AVERAGE)

  • 3 Agree Realty (ADC) | $65.63
  • 3 VICI Properties (VICI) | $23.00
  • 1 McDonald's (MCD) | $231.40
  • 1 Watsco (WSO) | $304.00
  • 5 Amplify Intl. Dividend Income ETF (IDVO) | $41.59
  • 6 Schwab Intl. Dividend ETF (SCHY) | $31.28
  • 3 Schwab U.S. Dividend ETF (SCHD) | $33.07

💰 GOING EX-DIVIDEND THIS WEEK 💰

  • 10/5 General Electric (GE), 0.61% | 70S
  • 10/6 Toro (TTC), 1.58% | 84VS
  • 10/7 Comcast (CMCSA), 6.12% | 60BS
  • 10/8 Intuit (INTU), 1.96% | 98VS
  • 10/8 Main Street Capital (MAIN), 5.77% | 62S
  • 10/9 Darden Restaurants (DRI), 3.23% | 70S
  • 10/9 AT&T (T), 4.57% | 70S
  • 10/9 Mastercard (MA), 0.63% | 99VS

🔥Special Offers!🔥

Simply Safe Dividends is a resource I use every single day. It's run by a handful of very knowledgable HUMANS and updated constantly. And with this offer, you can try it FREE for 14 days with absolutely NO credit card required! 👉Check it out!


Access Seeking Alpha's proven stock ratings, data-driven insights, and institutional-grade tools for just $269 for your first year.:

  • Seeking Alpha Premium: $269/year (Save $30 + 7-day free trial)

If you want data-driven insights and professional stock ratings to help grow your portfolio, grab the deal while it lasts. 👉 [Claim your discount here!]

*These are affiliate offers, and I will receive a small commission at no additional cost when you buy a premium annual subscription after clicking the images or links above.


video preview​

In case you missed it, find out about the WEIRDEST dividend king!


🎶Random music from the Dapper Dividends Jukebox🎶

Silent Horror - Wolfsbane

video preview​

🎙️Check out the Dapper Dividends Jukebox!🎶

Are you cursed with too much money? Consider my TIP JAR as a last resort before lighting it on 🔥!


Hey, you made it to the end of the newsletter!

Congratulations!

How did you like it? Do you have any suggestions for improving it? Please let me know here.

That said, have a WONDERFUL week, and I'll see you in the next one.


Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Copyright (C) *2025*DapperDividends*All rights reserved.

Dapper Dividends

Each week you'll learn how to be a better dividend investor and follow the journey of a welder with a passion for passive income to $1,000,000 and beyond.

Read more from Dapper Dividends

Since 2020, I’ve been adding to a spreadsheet that now has over 2,300 pieces of investing and life wisdom. Anytime I read or hear something that makes me think, I add it. It’s easy because it’s on my phone, which always seems to be within arm’s reach! When I get bored of the same old social media posts, I pull up the spreadsheet and flip to something random that I saved and probably forgot about. That’s exactly what I want to share with you here. This week’s random pick comes from Peter...

As I write this, my wife Jena is down with a migraine. She has had them her whole life, and if you’ve never had one, it can literally wipe out a whole day. And I wish there were a simple way just to make it stop for her. That got me thinking about something I have heard said about investing. Some of the best companies to look at for the long term are the ones that solve migraine-level problems. The kind of problem people will gladly pay to make go away, over and over again. So I found a few...

I think I might be addicted to a dividend. Nobody needs to stage an intervention, but I own a stock that pays about 10%, and every time I think about selling it, I find a reason not to. And lately I've been wondering if the reason is just... Loving watching that money roll in every 90 days! What got me thinking about all this was when Ares Capital (ARCC) reported earnings, and on top of that, they announced they're buying another company called MidCap Financial (MFIC) in a deal worth about...