Each week you'll learn how to be a better dividend investor and follow the journey of a welder with a passion for passive income to $1,000,000 and beyond.
Share
⏳Paying for 60 Years of Earnings?!
Published 4 months ago • 4 min read
A dividend investing forum will be held on March 5th, 2025, and you can attend for FREE. Details are below.
It made me think about Costco (COST), a company I love, with its sky-high P/E ratio of 61.72.
Yahoo! Finance
Then Marks explained something that grabbed me: buying a stock at a P/E of 16 (the historical average since WW2) means you're paying for 20+ years of a company's future earnings discounted back to today.
Because of inflation, today's dollar is worth more than tomorrow's. If a company would make $1M next year and then shut down, you'd pay less than $1M to get a positive return.
It clicked that at Costco's current P/E of 61.72, I'm paying $62 for each $1 of annual earnings – for a company that's only existed for 42 years! To justify today's price based solely on current earnings (with no growth), you'd need Costco to maintain its performance for far longer than it has even existed.
So I'm sticking to my guns and waiting for a better price, even if it means missing out. After all, the S&P 500 just had its best two-year run since right before the dot-com bubble burst. Marks' data shows that whenever people bought the S&P at P/E ratios similar to today's 22x multiple, they earned ten-year returns between +2% and -2%.
I'm also content getting my Costco exposure through an S&P 500 index fund. Looking at the latest weightings, Costco is ranked #16, meaning about $0.91 of every $100 I invest in the S&P 500 flows into Costco. Of course, this works both ways—if market sentiment shifts and selling begins, that amount flows out just as automatically.
SlickCharts.com
Companies trading at high P/Es are essentially "priced for perfection." Any stumble, any slight miss in earnings, and the stock gets hammered. You're paying a premium for flawless execution and continued high growth.
Sometimes it's okay to say "if I miss it, I miss it" – there will always be other opportunities. The market doesn't reward FOMO investors in the long run.
And, Costco's P/E is WAY above the sector average of 17X earnings. Using Costco's 5-year average P/E of 37 and their current earnings per share of $18 would give us a share price of $686. But, given that Costco is a dominant company, I'd feel comfortable paying a 10% - 20% premium and buying in the $750 to $800 range.
Click the image above, sign up for a 7-day free trial, get $30 off an annual PREMIUM SeekingAlpha.com subscription, and check out the Dividend Investing Forum.
But you can check this out FREE if you sign up for Premium and cancel after March 5th as long as it falls within a 7-day window.
Speakers: Steven Bavaria, Steven Cress, Rob Isbitts, Scott Kaufman, Samuel Smith and Dividendology.
*This is an affiliate offer, and I will receive a small commission at no additional cost when you buy a premium annual subscription after clicking the image above.
Special offer: $30 off Premium for the first year. At the end of the free trial (or immediately if you are no longer eligible for a free trial), $269 is charged automatically for the first year of your annual subscription. Auto-renews at the then current annual list price.
Each week you'll learn how to be a better dividend investor and follow the journey of a welder with a passion for passive income to $1,000,000 and beyond.
I'm writing this from our corner rental unit in the heart of Edinburgh, Scotland, which the locals pronounce "Ed-In-Bruh." My 16-year-old daughter Josie is a massive Harry Potter fan and has dreamed of visiting the UK since she was a little girl. We finally decided to make her dream come true. Our ten-day trip began in London and will end in a few days when we leave Scotland. Some of the Potter things we've done: taking a private filming location tour in London, Oxford, and medieval Lacock...
In the newsletter today I shared an incorrect screenshot of the total return of VTI vs FZROX since inception. I re-ran the comparison after a discussion on social media and I was in error. It appears FZROX underperformed VTI by almost 3%, which defeats the basis for my decision. Please disregard today’s main topic and my editor is looking for a new job. My sincerest apologies for any confusion this may have caused. ~Russ Unsubscribe · Preferences Copyright (C) *2025*DapperDividends*All rights...
I can't believe it. I'm actually going to be selling The Vanguard Total Stock Market Fund (VTI) this week. I know, I know. This is the same guy who has been preaching VTI as if it were the gospel of investing. The same fund that's making my wife look like a stock market genius when she started automatically investing $50 a week in December 2023 and has a 28.08% gain as of June 2025. The same VTI that I call the "easy button" for anyone who wants to own the entire US stock market without...
